Posted by Nick Karn on 5/19/2012, 3:10 pm, in reply to "Band rating question"
24.0.161.62
Considering Rush, Black Sabbath and Van Der Graaf Generator have multiple A's, B's and C's while Big Star have only one album in the letters, I could see the argument for rating them lower there, but what about the case of Derek And The Dominos and Syd Barrett? If Layla and The Madcap Laughs were their only releases available, would there really be a two star difference between them in rating despite only a one letter grade difference between the albums? Especially considering so much of Barrett is more Floyd than Syd and Opel is just an archive release.
--Previous Message--
: This has probably been addressed before, but
: 12-11-10 isn't good enough to get a 2 star
: rating? Does it matter that #1 Record is a B
: instead of a C and Radio City a 9 instead of
: an A?
:
: --Previous Message--
: Yeah, like there was any chance I was giving
: Big Star more than a one star rating.
:
: Also, there's an easter egg in one of the
: reviews. I'm not saying what it is but I'm
: kinda proud of it. See if you can find it.
:
:
:
