Sure they may be elements about his songwriting or keyboard playing that annoys people but if you like the band than obviously the positives he has strongly outweighs the negative by a large margin.
I don't have a problem with people criticising Banks but it's pretty stupid to say Genesis is great with the exception of Tony banks.
: Without Banks "Trick" would have
: been terrible, because Tony Banks wrote most
: of the album. He helped write every single
: song on the album. Rutherford is only
: credited on four tracks and Collins and
: Hackett are on three. Without Tony Banks
: Genesis would not have been Genesis. ANd
: that applied to almost *all* of their
: output. Any negatives he brings to the table
: are impossible to eliminate because to
: eliminate Banks would be to also eliminate
: just about everything that you love about
Message Thread | This response ↓
« Back to index