Don't 60% of the comments on the Rush page discount John's criticisms because he can't play as well as them (even though he actually praises their raw instrumental talent in the introduction and makes it absolutely clear that that's nothing to do with his criticisms*)?

*Makes me wish that my mentor had a review site. A good guitarist himself, he maintains his opinion that Geddy's the only really talented guy in the band. He kind of seems to feel that Lifeson's too simple (this is the vibe I got when he showed me that the Red Barchetta riff is simple harmonics) and that Peart...well, a lot of people have the drum machine problem with him.

--Previous Message--
: But dear God, do I miss the Andinos. I also
: with we'd hear more from that absolutely
: insane man, Mark Edwards, who sent a long,
: rambling comment for the intro on the Rush
: page, where he kept calling John
: "stoo" and said my favorite quote
: from any of John's comments ever:
:
: "A philosophy for 14 year olds, huh?
: Well, here is the problem. A dumb 14 year
: old is surely dumb. What do you get when he
: turns 50? A dumb professor!"
:
: I want him to comment on everything.
:
: --Previous Message--
: Are there any former review commentators
: whose
: input you miss? (I ask because the Andinos
: made for interesting contrast whenever they
: popped up.)
:
:
: