When I first discovered John's page, like 8 or 9 years ago (holy shit, I wish I hadn't thought about how long ago that was), I thought the same thing. That was mostly because of their Bob Dylan pages, though - they share a lot of very specific opinions about him that aren't at all common among Dylan fans.

However, I think that other than a few pages here and there, John really doesn't have that much in common with George. I don't think the title is as deserving as it once might have been, and I think most other people realize that, too.