Back in the day, I started putting Kraft (I think?) 1,000 Island Dressing on my homemade burgers. It's not the same, but it was close enough for me! (They've probably changed it, but that was a few decades ago.)
I think that what all you put on it matters, too, as well as the order on the burger. Okay, now I want a real hamburger, lol!
Love All Life; Thank You For Posting! :)