from outside. I also used these to help get her house trained.
She gets a Purina DentaLife once a day. I break it in half, and she gets half for her morning run and the other half for her afternoon run. If I am too slow getting it, she lets me know. She gets know treat for her late night run and never expects one.
Dh will give her a piece of banana or apple (no seeds) when he is eating one. We never feed her from the table or let her know her food is coming from the table.
I never give Greenies, rawhide, or anything of that nature. I have seen dogs with impaction from those things. In addition, a lot of the commercial type animal parts are loaded with salt.
The cats rarely get treats as they don't seem to like them a lot. Also, Beau and Thomas have such sensitive systems. They throw up if something doesn't work with them. I have finally found a food (Blissful Belly by Blue Buffalo) that has greatly helped this problem