Hello David,

Congratulations on your TV debut, who knows where this will lead, Clarkeson, Wilson and Needell had better watch out.

Seriously though the show was reasonably entertaining but the factual part may have been a bit lost. Personally as this was "Young MECHANIC of the year" I felt there was too much emphasis on electrical problems and not enough on overall mechanical ability.

Although I know your baby is tuning cars I believe this is a specialised area that only a very small percentage of people move into So I don't think it was the best test to show who is the best of the UKs YOUNG mechanics.

Having said that it is easy for us to sit in front of the TV and a computer screen and judge without all the facts to hand.

We have no idea of how the 5 finalists were chosen or how they faired in previous tasks.

regarding the budget you mention, Surely hiring Silverstone for the day would have eaten up most of that.

Lets hope if this becomes an annual competition they will take on board any constructive criticism and use it to improve the competition and not just to improve the show.

One thing that may affect its longevity is that TV is driven by viewing figures so if the show proves to have been unpopular, it may not be re-filmed next year.

Regards,

Mike

ps >>>This competition was widely publicised in the media and this forum, perhaps some of the young critics here would like to enter next year? I personally look forward to your applications in the next series!!<<<<

If they opened the age limit to Under 50s I would be happy to apply.