The Lifeboat News
[ Message Archive | The Lifeboat News ]

    Simplicius: NATO Plans for Ukraine Leaked Archived Message

    Posted by sashimi on April 8, 2023, 6:39 am

    (quote)
    But before we dive in, a few contextualizing words. Firstly, despite the
    absolute authenticity of the documents at first glance, several things should be
    said as a precursor.

    1. The initial copies which circulated all over Telegram were altered by
    [presumably] a Russian source who changed (photoshopped) the 'Losses' data,
    however original versions have now been found. (more on this later)

    2. One obvious consideration is that this leak could be a mass deliberate
    maskirovka campaign by NATO/U.S. to fool Russia with seemingly authentic
    information on the offensive, which would intentionally steer Russian defenses
    in the wrong direction, etc.

    So bear these considerations in mind. Yes, there is still a possibility that it
    is basically disinfo. Particularly because the timing of the leaked release so
    "conveniently" falls right on the eve of the big AFU offensive.

    Reuters claims the following:
    Previous Message
    Russia or pro-Russian elements are likely behind the leak of several classified
    US military documents posted on social media, Reuters reported.


    However, there are certain extenuating circumstances that heavily point to the
    leaks being real. Which are namely that: there is apparently a much larger trove
    of leaked data that is floating around, in fact most of it is not even related
    to Russia / Ukraine and is in fact much more serious and 'sensitive' as per
    U.S. sources, as it pertains to highly secretive internal transmissions
    regarding China, the Middle East, and more. You can read about it on this new
    NYTimes article.

    And secondly, there are a lot of pieces of info in the leaks which wouldn't make
    logical sense in revealing if it was simple disinfo. For instance, revealing how
    many NATO/Western spy/intel assets are operating in Ukraine, etc. Such things
    only serve as evidence for Russia of U.S./West's collusion an secret
    provocations/escalations, and serve as future legal proof of the West being the
    antagonist and initiator in the conflict, which gives Russia major legal and
    geopolitical advantages. That to me is too big of an oversight.

    Also, the fact that much of it paints Russia in a favorable light, in terms of
    the pure numbers. If it was a deliberate leak, one would think they would sneak
    in some embarrassing or discrediting info about the Russian military, to paint
    it unfavorably, at least to some extent. Why let the world know how low Russia's
    losses really are, for instance?

    I'm partial to believing the flipside of the coin, which is that it was leaked
    on the eve of the offensive by disgruntled internal NATO employees wishing to
    sabotage the operation. Although it could be 'part of the plan', I don't think
    the Biden admin would go so hard in trying to scrub the data off the internet if
    it were a real disinfo campaign.

    And lastly, very little in the leak is actually 'surprising' or unknown
    information because much of it very accurately reflects all the projections that
    those of us who are on the ball have been making, and so it serves more as a
    confirmation of known facts. If it were true disinfo, I would expect that it
    would have some 'surprising' shocks that we didn't anticipate, which would
    attempt to steer our analysis in some deflected direction, but it in fact
    confirms everything we've been seeing and reporting in many significant ways.
    (/quote)
    -- Cont'd at https://simplicius76.substack.com/p/major-nato-plans-for-ukraine-leaked

    Message Thread:

    • Simplicius: NATO Plans for Ukraine Leaked - sashimi April 8, 2023, 6:39 am