Re: Bomber Harris, Dresden, Iraq & Palestine Archived Message
Posted by Ian M![](https://images.boardhost.com/invisible.gif) on November 25, 2023, 6:20 pm, in reply to "Bomber Harris, Dresden, Iraq & Palestine"
Somewhat off-topic, I went looking for a source for the Harris quote about 'one 250 lb. or 500 lb. bomb in each village that speaks out of turn' in response to the 1st Palestinian intifada, and tracked it down to this 1988 article in the LRB by dissident tory Ian Gilmour with his son Andrew: https://www.lrb.co.uk/the-paper/v08/n18/ian-gilmour/terrorism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ian_Gilmour,_Baron_Gilmour_of_Craigmillar Not much extra context provided apart from an odd celebration of Harris' 'consistency'. Would have to find it in the book he was reviewing, 'Britain's Civil Wars: Counterinsurgency in the Twentieth Century' by Charles Townshend. But worth reading the article if only for the extensive critique of the book, 'Terrorism: How the West can win' edited by one... Benjamin Netanyahu. He thoroughly demolishes Bibi's then contention that fighting terrorism represents a struggle 'between the forces of civilisation and the forces of barbarism’, and it's rather satisfying to read. Sample: 'The rest of the book, which is edited and partly written by Benjamin Netanyahu, the Israeli Ambassador to the UN and the brother of the hero of Entebbe, is, however, very different. Apart from the editor’s obtrusive commentaries, this consists of lectures given at the Jonathan Institute in Washington by George Shultz, Jeane Kirkpatrick, Arthur Goldberg, Moshe Arens, Eugene Rostow, Paul Johnson, Senator Cranston and many others with similar views. The blurb describes the book as a polemic, which it is, and ‘a comprehensive reasoned analysis’, which it is not. The thesis is that terrorism is an anti-Western phenomenon and the battle against it part of the struggle ‘between the forces of civilisation and the forces of barbarism’. ‘The two main antagonists of democracy in the post-war world,’ Mr Netanyahu tells us, are ‘Communist totalitarianism and Islamic radicalism’, and between them they have ‘inspired virtually all of contemporary terrorism’. That will be news to the people of Northern Ireland, who will be keen to know whether the IRA are totalitarian Communists or radical Muslims. According to Mr Netanyahu, terrorism does not stem from social misery and frustration. There are no ‘root causes’ of terrorism other than ‘the political ambitions and designs of expansionist states and the groups that serve them’. ‘One man’s terrorist’ is emphatically not ‘another man’s freedom fighter’. Terrorism, moreover, when successful, has ‘always ended in totalitarianism’. That should interest the Israelis and the Cypriots, who pride themselves on their democracy. Terrorism, Mr Netanyahu goes on, is ‘uniquely pervasive in the Middle East’, because of Islamic fundamentalism and Arab nationalism. It does not in any way result from the West’s or anybody else’s treatment of the Arabs. ‘The root cause of terrorism lies not in grievances but in a disposition towards unbridled violence,’ which in turn is caused by the belief that ‘certain ideological and religious goals justify, indeed demand, the shedding of all moral inhibitions.’ After all this, it is no surprise to learn that ‘the West will not be able to stem the tide of international terrorism without facing squarely this alliance in terror’ between the Communists and Muslims. In short, the West must line up behind Israel and against the Palestinians. The thesis of Terrorism: How the West can win (hereinafter known as ‘Netanyahu’) thus depends on the truth of these propositions: 1. Arab terrorism is quite unprovoked and springs from a mere propensity to violence. 2. Islam is a uniquely violent religion with an especially violent history which uniquely inspires terrorism and assassination. 3. There is very little terrorism in the world that is not either Communist- or Islamically-inspired or both. 4. The West is innocent of terrorism. [contd...]
|
Message Thread:
- Bomber Harris, Dresden, Iraq & Palestine - Ian M November 25, 2023, 3:38 pm
- John Newsinger on the British repression of the 1st Palestinian intifada - Ian M November 25, 2023, 3:43 pm
- Re: Bomber Harris, Dresden, Iraq & Palestine - Ian M November 25, 2023, 6:20 pm
- Re: Bomber Harris, Dresden, Iraq & Palestine - Keith-264 November 25, 2023, 10:53 pm
|
|