The Lifeboat News
[ Message Archive | The Lifeboat News ]

    Scott Ritter: Which nation is to blame for the collapse of US-Russian arms control? Archived Message

    Posted by sashimi on August 21, 2023, 5:49 am

    A debate between Scott Ritter and Jeffrey Fischer

    21 Aug 2023

    It is possible to have civil discussions about complex issues where two sides
    are in sharp disagreement. In the present matter, two individuals with relevant
    experience in the field of arms control have come together to debate the
    question, "Which nation is to blame for the collapse of US-Russian arms
    control?" Retired US Air Force Colonel Jeffrey Fischer argues that the blame
    falls on the shoulders of Russia, while Scott Ritter, a former weapons
    inspector, argues that it is the US who is at fault.

    Jeff and Scott agreed to each write 1,500-word arguments making their respective
    case, which were then exchanged "in the blind," meaning neither had knowledge of
    the other's position at the time they made their argument. They then each wrote
    a 500-word rebuttal. The product of this effort is provided here for others to
    read and form their own assessment regarding the question at hand. It is hoped
    that this type of professional, polite discourse can serve as an example of how
    difficult topics can be discussed void of the kind of rancor that often
    accompanies the issues that divide us.
    -- Cont'd at https://www.scottritterextra.com/p/which-nation-is-to-blame-for-the

    Message Thread: