So what? Do you think the man himself is concerned about shouldering this invented burden? He's got about 50 years of legendary career behind him; going out on a low note isn't going to ruin his reputation now. (Rumors of his impending death being greatly exaggerated at any rate). I say this is the perfect time for Bob to indulge his whims, Sinatra tributes included.

Besides, the trepidation greeting this album from Dylan fans who really should know better has the nasty scent of rock-centric closed-mindedness; Full Moon and Empty Arms is a gorgeous song as sung by Frankie, and not one bit less artistically valid because it happens to predate Rubber Soul. Likewise, Bob's vocal on the new version is of a quality which I no longer knew he was capable; and I'm not even one of thosr crazy people who thought Christmas in the Heart was beautifully sung.