The Lifeboat News
[ Message Archive | The Lifeboat News ]

    Re: stephen Corry: 'Pristine Wildernesses and Other Myths Peddled by the BBC' Archived Message

    Posted by margo on March 1, 2019, 12:43 pm, in reply to "stephen Corry: 'Pristine Wildernesses and Other Myths Peddled by the BBC'"

    Excellent article, thanks for posting.
    I always think of a dear old Zimbabwean lady I knew, "Mama Rhoda", whose stories I loved to hear. She lived along the Botswana border, not far from Bulawayo. Her biggest bugbear was the elephants that would frequently roam into her carefully tended maize and pumpkin fields: she and her sons had to come up with various McGyver plans to encourage the elephants to move elsewhere. They co-habited in a lovely symbiosis with the animals they respected.

    Reading the article, one also laughs at the tourists fooled by 'dinner time at the water hole' at so many expensive eco-lodges

    One gung-ho, pro-military documentary depicted heroic British soldiers (including Prince Harry) with guns over their shoulders taking on the rhino poachers in the Kruger Park, on the Mozambique border. These soldiers got the glory of a gorgeously-shot film shoot: the countless black South African rangers who've bravely taken on the poachers for years (some losing their lives) didn't get a mention, let alone the local communities dispossessed of land...
    Previous Message

    extract

    The wholly different narrative they expose begins with the revelation that protected areas were never “pristine wildernesses” in the first place; they were home to local peoples who actually created the “wild” ecosystems, and who were then thrown out and destroyed when parks were imposed by national governments. The grass plains of the Serengeti, the Amazon rainforest and so on, were all formed by vigorous human intervention over thousands of years. Experts now accept this, but it remains little known among the general public. Why? Because very few BBC nature viewers have ever been told the real history: After all, it profoundly undermines the fake one. The destruction of the original landowners, the creators and curators of the world’s “wildernesses”, is criminal in several respects. One is that they were often far better at maintaining biodiversity than the incoming, usually white, conservationists. The latter often fail, and usually blame the locals when things go wrong. Another point is just how protected these areas really are. They usually include an infrastructure specifically aimed at only the richest tourists. Most of the African parks marketed as “pristine wilderness” include roads, hotels (called “lodges,”to make them seem smaller), luxury “camps”, artificial water holes and salt licks to attract animals, airstrips, and so on. I have been in one where a leopard appeared every evening in perfect view of the hotel dining room, just as food was being served. The excited guests rarely stayed long enough to question what might lie behind this spectacular coincidence, but of course the tourists weren’t the only ones being fed by the hotel staff.

    Read more at: https://www.theelephant.info/culture/2019/02/15/an-inconvenient-truth-pristine-wildernesses-and-other-myths-peddled-by-the-bbc/
    The Elephant - Speaking truth to power.

    Message Thread: