I don't mind Peter Oborne, he's been pretty good on Israel, but...
Posted by Ed on September 9, 2026, 4:51 pm
...this sounds incredibly naive and just silly as far as Miliband, and Labour goes in relation to Israel. He says Miliband, might be the first foreign secretary this century to think "British values are something we stand up for..." What utter bollox!
"I won't dignify the attacker's words by repeating them, they are horrific and vile."
Re: I don't mind Peter Oborne, he's been pretty good on Israel, but...
As far as I can see this is the first rupture with Israel by any British Goverment since Ms Thatcher denounced the illegal invasion of Lebanon in summmer 1982 -in the holy name of Internatial Law. "International law is all we have". That was very much framed by Argentines illegal invasrion of the Falklands, using arms supplied by Israel.
The first serious breach by a british opposition party was in 2014 when the whole Labour=AS hysteria was triggered by an opposition leader whipping reluctant back benchers to recognise Palestine. That leader was Ed Miliband. That caused Maureen Lipman to make her first threat to seek safety in Israel - and so the Great Hysteria began
Oborne's mighty book Complicity nails the sale of F35 key components for bombing Gazas a key component of Complicity. He thinks this latest rupture is potentially a change of direction bringing Britain into line with international law and common decency. Bollox, argues Spartacus: If Miliband intended to suspend F-35 components he would already have done so. He has already had two months. Enough of this shilly shallying.
At least I assume that is the argument. But maybe there is no argument, merely a sectarian hissy-fit about a bit of Tory phraseology
gb
Re: I don't mind Peter Oborne, he's been pretty good on Israel, but...
I have more than a little sympathy for the Dave Spart view: it's the same government after all that ran 5-600 spying missions over Gaza before they claimed to stop last year, spending many millions in UK supposed "defense" funds to give Israel free up to the minute accurate coordinates to facilitate the efficient bombing of tents full of innocent women and children.
-Show me someone in Jail for that and I'll believe they are serious about adhering to International Law.
Re: I don't mind Peter Oborne, he's been pretty good on Israel, but...