I haven't made my own but I have some in cans. I am sure it isnt as good as homemade. Maybe I will get a can out on the counter and if I start feeling hungry I will heat some up and sip on it. It seems like I use to do that years ago on Cambridge. We all have to find out what works for us. Pam, I have been using a powdered kind called Native Path. Right now they have a special. 28 servings for 15.99. The liquid(canned) bone broth doesn't thicken up. My hair is growning back dark charcoal. I liked my silver color better, lol